10.30.2005

Serenity, Courage, Wisdom

God grant me the serenity to accept that I’m a woman and You’re a man,
The courage to ignore myself as a sexual being,
And the wisdom to keep my mouth shut.

Sometimes I just get so enraged I am afraid I will never be able to put words to it.

God please grant me the serenity to accept the things others will change,
I need the courage to change the things that I am able to,
And the wisdom to know how to act.

I read an article in the SNYT this morning and I am furious!* Sex and the Faithful Soldier. There are so many ways in which I can take issue with the subject, but instead I will present them and hope that the holy spirit will speak some truth and justice to people. To start, I think committed monogamous relationships are best and the way people engage with relational and personal sexuality can lead to problems when they do not live in balance, respect and love.

A group of people, with good intentions, have created a kit for men (don’t worry women, you get a spin-off) to help soldiers remain “pure” while in iraq. Please read this article, I am not going to quote the whole thing.

What makes me so upset are a few of the assumptions and conclusions that the authors of this kit are promoting:

1. Women are secondarily sexual beings: we are sexual for men, our sexuality is created by society, and that sex is an impulsive offering of ourselves to men who notice us.

This is pretty self explanatory, but a lot of people still think that a woman’s sexuality is for the purpose of a man, or not really sex-related but for the purpose of procreation. Come on!

2. Male sexuality is something violent and be dealt with violently: a “battle.”

This is just a problem, pure and simple, but it shouldn’t be a violent one. Sex topics should not be referred to in violent terms, it just perpetuates violent thinking and language potentially hurting others. Men are men, and they have hormones, bodies and they have self-control and it is something to engage with and employ properly. Buck up and take responsibility for yourself!

3. Masturbation is wrong and a sexual impurity.

I know a lot of people have issue with this, but I think it’s an issue of balance, heart and mind. If any of those are out of line, sure, it’s probably not a good idea, but that works for a lot of things (over eating, etc.).

4. That the woman’s kit comes with the “Life Recovery Bible” and the men get an “Every Man’s Bible.”

From what I have read, the “Life Recovery Bible” is outlined like a 12 step program for those who are in recovery. Don’t get me wrong, I think most people should engage with the 12 steps more often**. But, why do the women get that one in this kit? Why can’t you slap a fresh “Every Woman’s Bible” cover on any generic NIV? Is someone trying to communicate that women who want this kit or are offered this kit need to be recovering from something? Maybe just recovering from the sexual oppression and woman-hate that they have been forced to live with.

Anyway, that’s my rant/gibe for today. I expect some people to have different ideas on the subject. Know that as we (John, Dave and I) talked about this today, we were serious and humored in our conversation.

*There are other things I was furious about too: 1) the Bush administration, 2) the 25,902 Iraqi deaths from Jan ’04 to Sept ‘05 JUST in insurgent activity not including any US bombing or US acts, 3) the next supreme court nominee will probably be a ultra-conservative man.

**When envisioning a small group from time to time I have considered starting a 12 step program for those who are trying to live post-conservative-right-wing-evangelical-Christian. I think it would be wildly positive, popular and healing.

5 comments:

Grace said...

Katie! You are just looking for a fight. Well, you WONT get one from me. The only people who would fight you on this are the ones who think its appropriate to medicalize women's sexual experiences (12 step) and valorize men's (battle heros).

First, you're right that issues of sexuality can be a problem, especially for men who are marketed to much more than women - using the female body like a piece of consumable meat so that whenever they see women they think SEX (Its their eyes, women, NOT your bodies).

I do not take lightly the real addiction that sex can be for men and women. Any addiction can interupt our lives and cause pain to those around us. Sexual addiction is especially concerning because much of pornography reflects male domination over the female in act and narrative. Women are the object of male interest, the viewed one, the one getting things done to her. There are some serious concerns with violence and rape of women in porn that is totally legal. Hey, freedom of expression. Express this - (insert middle finger).

Second I would only worry about mastrbation when it completely replaces real live people. Like my 63 year old, conservative, Christian mother always says, "The Bible doesn't say anything about masturbation and I don't think there's anything wrong with it." (You go mom!)

Third, the sexual evils that SOME of our (young, barely/almost legal) soldiers act out in the countries they occupy (through rape, pregnancy, cheating, disease spreading, etc...) are very serious. But the concern of conservative Christians is NOT THOSE evils but instead the evil that they perceive is in indulging in raw human desire.

This is the realm of "dirty, filthy" bodies (you know, the ones that women/sex embody). The body is the site of evil (even though God created) and God forbid you enjoy it. I'd like to see them create a kit that's called "why you shouldn't reek havoc in the country you are 'freeing'. (And, by the way, please masturbate if it means staying out of trouble.)"

Grace said...

by the way, did you rewrite that serenity prayer? I LOVED it!

Grace said...

okay this is my third post I know...

I just wanted to add that "Every Man's Battle" is a program (of sorts) that was created to help Christian men recover from sexual addiction (especially porn). I have a therapist friend who is involved monthly with leading groups of men in dialogue about their addictions.

I didn't know they had a spin-off version for women and that they're marketing it to the soldiers. It sounds possibly helpful for men who want to stay faithful to their wives while away... but this 'no masturbation' deal? That's just unnecessarily setting them up for failure!

Kate said...

I did not go into the depth that there is good to the program or book, Every Man's Battle. Yes, sexual adiction is a terrible thing to struggle with and I am glad there are programs available for those who do and can be offered to those we know who do.

I did rewrite the prayer. The original is:

God grant me the serentity to accept the things I cannot change,
the courage to change the things I can,
and the wisdom to know the difference.

Anonymous said...

Hi, I have read Every Man's Battle and, yes, I disagree with the author's too strong stance on masterbation. However, the overall tone of the book is to see women as equals and not sexual objects, to respect them and the sexual relationship and to keep "pure" before and during marriage. It elevates a man from animal to a God-created being in His own image.

The series is directed at men but I highly recommend it as reading by women to understand the masculine paradigm.

John Sr.