12.08.2005

Living in Community

My friend Matt emailed me links to these websites. It got me all excited again about the possibility of living in community, sharing and giving. John always makes fun of me because my ideas sound too communist. He has to remind me that we do not living in a commune. “But wouldn’t it be great if all of us (our neighbors) did this or that and shared or borrowed?” I ask so often. Just the other day I was trying to figure out a way to get our apartment wireless with everyone involved…it’s not likely. But what if we all shared a vacuum, that’s reasonable right?

I have not fully explored these sites, but I will this evening. I have always been drawn to this style of living and now I see people are successfully living out their faith in ways that I can identify with. I love it. Thanks Matt. Let me know when you and Grace are ready, I’m there!

Caden House

The Ashram

8 comments:

Grace said...

I'm always appreciating these kinds of efforts to draw people into an 'alternative' lifestyle (a lifestyle that I believe should be the norm and not the exception) but there are 2 things that concern me out about these attempts.

First, they usually come across as communities that have the potential to be cult followings... literally.

Second, and more importantly, they often overlook the reality that class status plays a big factor in people being able to live healthy (what becomes "cool") lifestyles. Just because we (young, white, childless couples with potential for dual incomes) have the theoretical ability to buy all organic things does not mean that everybody does. Income is not the only measurement of wealth. Whether we know it or not, we have 'access' to wealth (parents or friends who could lend a helping hand if need be) as well as social categorization that helps us get jobs easily (i.e. white, educated people).

I just worry that a healthy lifestyle (which is not completely accessible to everyone) gets advertised by well-intended people as the "cool way to live" without realizing that many people couldn't buy a healthy lifestyle even if they wanted to.

*just something to keep in mind as we take advantage of our privileges and responsibilities - caring for the earth and doing justice for 'others'.

Grace said...

By the way, my response was not so much in response to katie's post as it was to the link to Caden House which I explored. I love Katies idea of sharing!

:)

Anonymous said...

I think all of these things are "true". Sometimes I get discouraged by "designer ethics" myself. That's why I would rather root myself in traditions of spiritual practice as an expression of living a just life.

Like Celtic Christianity, for instance. If you have a view of the earth that sees it as God's self-revelation, of which humans are a part; if you have a view of the earth that insists that life is inherently "good" although we learn to do evil things that can mask that "goodness", and the only way to overcome this is to practice the person of Jesus, these are things that keep me from simply "doing" something because I want to be cool or be designer or whatever.

Nor should we discount the probability that living in alternative communities like this may be the ONLY way to give an alternative vision for what people really can be and do. Perhaps for those that cannot currently make these choices, living in this way will make it more acceptable and perhaps available to wider groups. I just can't find a way to seriously criticize living according to my own values; nor can I find a way to fail to acknowledge that I must work to make it possible for others to do the same. In fact, these communities probably certainly do more for those in need than, say, a suburban subdivision.

As for the cult thing, we were just discussing this in class yesterday. "Cult" is a term that we use, usually, to describe those groups that seem weird to us. It's a form of "othering". In social science terms, however, a "cult" is defined at least in part by a strong, hierarchical leadership, usually a single overpowering personality. Unless anyone believes I am a cult leader in the making, I don't think we have any worries.

On second thought, don't answer that last question. LOL

That's where I am right now.

Anonymous said...

I have spent a good deal of time the past several months thinking about what Christian life and community would look like were they to measure up to the revolutionary, counter-cultural expression found in the words and work of Jesus. For most of my life, the idea of being “in the world, not of it” (to drop a little bumper-sticker theology on you) meant little more than going to church, not drinking beer, and not having sex.

Now this won’t come as a galloping shock to anyone who reads Katie’s blog, but living counter-culturally in today’s society has got to mean more than simply living by a personal, pietistic moral code if we are to make any difference in the world around us. Instead, a revolutionary life centered on the person of Jesus must offer an alternative to the isolated, individualistic consumerism that defines today’s culture. A counter-cultural Christianity would be characterized by a life lived in community – celebrating our joys, sharing our burdens, mourning our losses – rather than living by the American code of being self-contained, self-sufficient, pulling ourselves up by our bootstraps. It would mean creatively and thoughtfully managing the resources we have – using only what we need and giving away the rest to those who need – rather than falling into the American pattern of blindly and compulsively buying and consuming more, more, more.

I haven’t looked at the websites Matt sent this morning, but a life lived in intentional Christian community would be a significant step toward offering a real and vital alternative to the lonely, desperate search for significance that define the lives of so many. Will this be difficult? Of course. And I agree with Grace that there are a number of dangers inherent in these types of communities, the foremost in my mind being a tendency to exclusivity and isolation that would torpedo the good that could emanate from communities like these.

But here’s something you might agree with as well: the way we’ve been doing church and the ways we’ve been living the Christian life aren’t working for many in our generation. I have been having conversations for years with people who have grown up in the church culture and found it at best irrelevant to individual and societal ills; many more outside the church think Christians and Christianity are a large part of what is wrong in the first place. The church culture in which some of us were raised doesn’t seem to address the deep-seated selfishness we find in our own souls, and it certainly doesn’t address the structural evils and social injustices we are overwhelmed with every day. I don’t just need a little help to become someone who lives and loves like Jesus; I need total and continual transformation. But this won’t happen on its own, and I won’t get it done on my own. It won’t happen by reading a book or attending a conference, and I won’t be able to do it by sheer force of will.

A Christian life and community that lived up to the revolutionary, counter-cultural expression found in the words and work of Jesus would change the world in ways I don’t think we can even begin to imagine - not by forcefully legislating morals but by peacefully, radically transforming lives.

So maybe instead of tinkering around the edges of the way things are, what we need is something radically different.

That’s where I am right now.

dbj

Anonymous said...

**AMEN**

----THAT'S RIGHT----

PREACH it.

^^^^^C'MON, NOW^^^^^

UmmmmmmHmmmmm....

Grace said...

I love having so many eloquent, realistic and positive people around me! God knows the positive part could rub off on me a little more. ;)

Oh, Momma! said...

Hey Katie,

Thanks for your thoughts on community living. Sorry I'm a little late on this conversation. I've always been kind of a late bloomer. If you know what I mean...

Michael and I have been batting that thought for a looong time now. And I'm glad Matt, shared with you the two working and living communities. They were very interesting to peruse.

I love the idea of community living but I guess my worry comes from continuing the whole 'Christian Bubble' or any kind of bubble for that matter. Not to say that that there aren't Christians living the kind of life jesus proclaimed us to live, with out the bubble, but that I feel there would be too much of an enticement to create a mass number of bubbles that don't allow for true community beyond one's 'own kind of people'.

It's obviously working based on the websites I saw but I guess, not to be negative, but I worry that it could very easily become insulated, even while doing 'good work'.

I hope this wasn't too much of a downer and that it makes some kind of sense.

Kate said...

I never assumed that "my community" would be made of people who all have the same views and beliefs. I've recently been having some fantastic converstions with some people at work that have given me hope on a more inclusive and diverse "community." In the end I will probably never live on a comune, but I do hope to surround myself with people who would make it difficult to be labled at an exclusive community of any sort (faith, economics, style, hobbies, language, etc.).